Choosing Troughing Idlers: Trough Angle, CEMA Class, and Spacing

·

Trough angle, CEMA class, and idler spacing are one decision, not three. This guide shows what the published tables say. The guide also shows how the ratings go down on a wide belt, and what changes when someone builds the frame around the answer.

Choosing troughing idlers means deciding three numbers: trough angle, CEMA class, and spacing. Most people decide them one at a time. The three numbers are not independent. If you deepen the trough on a wide belt, the load rating of the same idler goes down. If you spread the sets out, belt sag increases with the square of the spacing. This guide explains what each number does and what the published tables say. The guide also explains how to decide the three numbers together, from the viewpoint of the shop that builds the frame around your answer.

The Three Numbers Are One Decision

Trough angle determines how much material the belt holds and how flexible the belt must be. CEMA class determines how much weight one idler set carries and how long its bearings last. Spacing determines how much of that weight each set carries and how far the belt sags between the sets. If you change one number, the other two change.

Most spec sheets give you the three numbers separately. If you pick them that way, you find out at startup that the belt will not trough at 45 degrees. Or you find out that the class you paid for lost a third of its rating on a wide belt.

What a Deeper Trough Gives, and What It Costs

Trough angle is measured on the wing rolls, from horizontal. North American practice uses three trough angles: 20, 35, and 45 degrees. Most of the gain from a deeper trough comes in the first steps. Published comparisons show an increase of roughly 27 percent in cross-sectional area from 20 to 35 degrees. The same comparisons show an increase of roughly 37 percent from 20 to 45 degrees. If you compare those two figures, the last step (35 to 45 degrees on the same belt) adds about 8 percent. The first fifteen degrees give most of the gain. The last ten degrees give little and cost the most.

What the deeper trough costs:

  • A more flexible belt. ISO 703 measures transverse flexibility as troughability. Troughability is the ratio of how far a belt sample deflects under its own weight to the belt width. A thick, heavily reinforced belt troughs at 20 degrees, but it resists troughing at 45 degrees.
  • Longer transitions at both ends. To reach a deeper trough, the belt edges travel farther than the center. The extra edge travel makes the transition longer. The longer transition adds frame length at the head and the tail.
  • Less free belt edge for the skirt seal. If the skirtboard width stays constant, the free edge outboard of the skirtboard shrinks as the trough deepens. At 35 degrees there is barely room left for a sealing system.

A deeper trough also has less tolerance for a belt that mistracks. In practice, 35 degrees is the common carrying angle for bulk material. A 20-degree trough has the best tolerance for thick belts and big lumps. One rule holds at any angle. Size the belt width on about 85 percent of the CEMA full cross-sectional area, not 100 percent. The remaining area is your allowance for surge loads, off-center loading, and normal mistracking.

CEMA Class: What the Letter Rates

CEMA, the Conveyor Equipment Manufacturers Association, classifies troughing and return idlers B through F. The letter shows two things. The first is standard dimensions, so idlers from different makers interchange in the same frame. The second is a load rating tied to a minimum bearing life. The letter is not a grade of toughness, and it is not an abrasion rating.

Ratings are based on bearing L10 life at 500 rpm. This bearing life is the life that 90 percent of a batch is expected to meet or exceed before fatigue failure. Classes B and C are rated on a minimum of 30,000 hours. Classes D and E are rated on a minimum of 60,000 hours. Bore and shaft diameter increase with the class, from around 17 mm at class B to around 50 mm at class F.

CEMA classRoll diametersBelt widthsPublished load rating, lb per idler set
B4", 5"18" to 48"410
C4", 5", 6"18" to 60"900
D5", 6"24" to 72"1,200
E6", 7"36" to 96"1,800
F6", 7", 8"60" to 96"3,000

The figures in the table are what the classes are sold on. The class, roll diameter, and belt width columns follow CEMA Standard 502. The load ratings are as published by Martin Sprocket, PPI, Nordstrong and Superior. These makers agree to the pound on the rating of all five classes. The offering varies a little at the ends of the range. PPI extends its own class F table past 96" at a lower rating. This extension is that maker's own, not part of the class. Some makers also sell an E-plus series above class E. The E-plus series is a manufacturer extension, not a CEMA class. The series has its own shaft and bearing size. In that maker's lineup, this size is between the sizes that class E and class F use.

The Derating That the Class Rating Does Not Show

Those numbers are the highest rating in each class. The ratings hold across the narrow end of each class's belt-width range at all three trough angles, then go down as the belt gets wider. Note what the rating assumes. Published troughing idler ratings are based on a load split of 70 percent on the center roll and 15 percent on each wing roll. The rating uses the same split for all three angles. In the rating, the angle does not move load outboard. Instead, the angle shows its effect in the longer roll and shaft that a deeper trough needs. The table reduces the rating for this only on a wide belt.

These class C figures come from a published rating table. The rating is 900 lb on an 18", 24", or 30" belt at any of the three angles. On a 36" belt, the rating is 900 lb at 20 degrees, 837 lb at 35 degrees, and 810 lb at 45 degrees. On a 60" belt, the ratings at the same three angles are 700 lb, 650 lb, and 630 lb. That last figure is 30 percent under the number the class is sold on.

Apply those figures to the angle decision. On a 60" belt, deepening the trough from 20 to 45 degrees gives about 37 percent more cross-sectional area. In the same change, the idler loses 10 percent of its load rating.

Class for Abrasive Material Is the Wrong Question

People ask constantly what class they need for abrasive material. The class table cannot answer this question. The letter rates load and bearing life. Abrasion destroys idlers in a different way: grit works past the seal and into the bearing, and the roll seizes. A seized roll under a moving belt stops rolling and cuts the belt. The answers are options inside whichever class the load requires.

  • The seal stack. The seal stack decides idler life in grit. Nobody compares it on a quote. A well-made idler stacks a contact seal, a grease-filled labyrinth, and a centrifugal flinger chamber. Contaminants then never have a direct path to the bearing.
  • Shell gauge. Published minimums run to 9 gauge tubing on class C and class D rolls. However, wall thickness is an option code, not a fixed attribute of the class. Martin lists 9, 7 and 4 gauge across C, D and E alike. Superior specifies class E in quarter-inch wall. A heavier wall is an option inside a class. You do not have to change class to get it. Makers list it as available on request. Most quotes never mention it. If the material is abrasive, ask for the wall by name. Do not assume that the class letter provides it.
  • Roll covering. Published selection has three steps. Most quotes stop at the first step. Plain steel tube is for material that is not sticky, corrosive, or abrasive. Rubber disc rolls are for material that is sticky, corrosive, or abrasive. Covered rolls are the next step, for material that is very sticky or very abrasive.

Use the same method that you use to pick steel for a chute or a bed. First name the failure mode. Then pick the part. That argument is in stainless vs abrasion-resistant steel.

Roll Diameter Is a Belt Speed Decision

Diameter is treated as a sign of heavy duty, but it is about revolutions. At the same belt speed, a 4" roll turns 50 percent more rpm than a 6" roll. So it uses up its bearing life faster, and it has a thinner shell. The rule of thumb links diameter to belt speed. The rule gives about 4" up to 400 feet per minute, 5" around 500 feet per minute, and 6" around 600 feet per minute. The diameter increases from there. The class limits the choice. If the speed needs a 7" roll, the class is E, whether or not the load needs class E.

Spacing: The Number That Changes the Other Two

Spacing is the cheapest thing to change on the conveyor and is also the thing most often left at the value on the last drawing. Two things depend on spacing.

First, load per set. The weight on one idler is roughly the weight per foot of the belt plus the material, times the spacing. If you halve the spacing, you halve the load on each set. Halving the spacing is often how a lighter class becomes a valid choice under a heavy belt. Do not size the idler to that product alone, though. The published calculated idler load first multiplies the material weight by a lump factor and then adds a misalignment load as a separate term.

Pay attention to the misalignment term. The misalignment term is load that the idler carries because of how square the frame holds the idler, not because of anything on the belt. No idler catalog can quote this load, because it is not a property of the idler. Whoever builds and sets the frame determines this load. The misalignment load is the reason two conveyors that carry the same material at the same spacing do not wear idlers at the same rate.

Second, sag. Sag depends on the square of the spacing. The catenary between two sets is (Wb + Wm) x Si² / 8T. In this formula, Si is spacing in feet and T is belt tension in pounds. If you reduce the spacing from five feet to four feet at the same tension, sag drops about 36 percent. CEMA does the calculation in the other direction. You set a sag limit, and then you solve for the tension that you must hold. The limits are 3, 2, and 1.5 percent of the spacing. The limit is chosen based on lump size, how much of the stream is lumps rather than fines, and the trough angle. If the limit goes from 3 percent to 1.5 percent at the same spacing, the required tension exactly doubles. That tension acts on the belt, the take-up, and the drive.

Normal ranges, before that arithmetic narrows them:

Belt widthCarrying idler spacingReturn idler spacing
18"4.5 to 5.5 feet8 to 10 feet
36"3.5 to 5 feet8 to 10 feet
60"3 to 4 feet8 to 10 feet
96"2 to 3.5 feet8 to 10 feet

Return rolls have their own rating. This rating is far below the carrying rating on the same line of the same table. For a 36" belt, a class C set is rated 900 lb, but the class C return under it is rated 200 lb. On belts wider than 48", the published tables stop quoting a class C return at all. The tables send you to a class D return instead. So the carrying side and the return side can correctly be in two different classes on one conveyor. This split is normal and becomes a problem only when all the idlers for a machine are ordered from a single class letter.

Closer spacing costs money twice. There are more idlers to buy, and more idlers that someone has to reach. Closely spaced sets leave no room to lay an idler on its side to change it. That trade-off is explained in slider bed vs roller bed conveyor.

The Load Zone Gets Sized Separately

Everything above describes the carrying run. The load zone, where the material lands, is a different problem with its own spacing and support. None of the carrying-run spacing numbers apply there. In the load zone, idlers are spaced at half the normal spacing or less. Published selection examples space the idlers in the load zone as close as a foot on centers, compared with four feet elsewhere on the run.

One fact is missed on impact idlers. The rating does not go up. An impact troughing idler with three equal-length rolls has the same published load rating as the standard idler in its class. Published guidance is explicit: treat impact idler ratings as no higher than standard ratings. The rubber protects the belt cover but adds no load rating. So the rubber is never the reason that a set can be spaced wider.

Idlers in that position also have a duty limit. Published guidance puts the limit for impact idlers at roughly 3" to 4" minus material that drops 6 to 8 feet. Above that, continuous support does better. Impact beds are for material of around 5" to 6" with a drop of 8 to 10 feet. Heavier cradles are for duty above that. If nothing rotates in the drop zone, there are no bearings to fail there. There is also no sag under the skirt seal, where fines escape and a trapped lump gouges the belt cover.

One more option is worth asking about: use 20-degree idlers through the load zone, and change to 35-degree idlers after the load zone. The shallower trough leaves free belt edge for the seal and also gives less edge stress at the point where the material hits the belt. See troughing idler conveyors for the conveyor around that zone.

Transition Zones Are Part of the Angle Decision

The transition is the distance from the centerline of the terminal pulley, where the belt is flat, to the first fully troughed idler. If the transition is too short, the belt edges are stretched against a center that has not moved. The stretching creases the belt at the idler junctions and eventually tears the belt.

The distance is a multiple of belt width. The multiple is neither small nor fixed. Published charts relate the multiple to three things. The first is the trough angle. The second is the belt carcass (fabric or steel cord). The third is the belt's working tension as a percentage of its rated tension. A worked example from the belting side shows how large the multiple is. The example is a fabric belt at 35 degrees that runs at 70 percent of its rated tension. This belt needs a full-trough transition of about two and a half times the belt width. If you give the same belt a transition of three quarters of a belt width, the edge tension goes above 130 percent. At the same time, the center of the belt goes slack and lifts off the center roll. The results are splice tearing at the edges and delamination along the center. A deeper trough means a longer transition, because the edges have farther to travel. A stiffer carcass means a still longer transition. DIN 22101 is the usual basis and limits edge stress.

Standard practice is to bring the belt to full trough in steps, not all at once. A 20-degree transition idler goes ahead of a 35-degree set. Both a 20-degree idler and a 35-degree idler go ahead of a 45-degree set. Bringing the belt to full trough in steps adds two or three extra idler positions at each end. The frame must include these positions. Trough angle is a frame decision, not a parts decision.

Deciding the Three Together

Remcon designs and fabricates troughing idler conveyors to order. So we size idler diameter, class, and spacing to the application, and we quote them per job. We do not take them from a catalog page. Belt widths across the line range from 12" to 72". Long conveyors ship in bolted sections, so there is a field joint in the line of idlers. The line of idlers has to be square again on site.

To size the three numbers, we need to know the material and its bulk density. We also need the largest lump and roughly how much of the stream is lumps rather than fines. We need the belt width and speed, the run and the lift, and the drop height at the load point. We also need to know where the conveyor is located, so we know how reachable the idlers will be. If the belt line on the quote is unclear, start with how to read a conveyor belt spec. Drive sizing is in conveyor drive and bearing specs.

We design and weld each conveyor at our Airway Heights, Washington shop. We then ship and install it nationwide with our own crews. We supply replacement parts for the life of the conveyor. The rest of the line is on the conveyors page. Get a quote or call (509) 244-9439.

Here is a worked example from a sand-handling job that we built in 2012. The idler line on the drawing reads: PPI, CEMA class C, 18" belt, 5" rolls, 35-degree carrying trough, 20-degree flat return. Read this as an example of how the three numbers fit together, not as a recommendation. An 18" belt is narrow, so the 5" roll is more than enough at that width. The 35-degree trough gives the section that the layout needed, without requiring a narrow belt to fold more than it easily can. A wider belt or a heavier drop would have changed all three numbers. The class for your conveyor depends on the job. If a builder names a class before asking what you are moving, that builder has not done the arithmetic.

Troughing Idler Selection FAQ

What is the difference between a CEMA C and a CEMA D idler?

Class D is the heavier rating. Published tables rate class C at 900 lb per idler set and class D at 1,200 lb. The bearing life basis increases with the class. Class C is rated on a minimum L10 of 30,000 hours and class D on 60,000 hours, both at 500 rpm. Class C covers 18" to 60" belts with 4", 5", and 6" rolls. Class D covers 24" to 72" belts with 5" and 6" rolls on a larger shaft. You do not always have to choose one class or the other. For example, past 48" of belt, published tables stop listing a class C return roll. The tables send you to a class D return under a class C carrying set.

What CEMA idler class do I need for abrasive material?

The class letter does not answer that. CEMA class rates load and bearing life, not wear. Abrasive material destroys idlers by working grit past the seal into the bearing until the roll seizes. A seized roll cuts a groove in the belt cover. The options that address abrasion are inside whichever class the load requires. These options are the seal stack, the shell gauge, and the roll covering. For the shell gauge, published minimums run to 9 gauge tubing on class C and D rolls. However, wall thickness is an option code, not a fixed attribute of the class. Martin lists 9, 7 and 4 gauge across C, D and E alike. Superior specifies class E in quarter-inch wall. For the roll covering, published selection puts rubber disc rolls on abrasive material and covered rolls on very abrasive material. Size the class to the load. Then spend money on seals and shell.

How much does trough angle change the cross-sectional area?

Published comparisons show an increase in cross-sectional area of about 27 percent from 20 to 35 degrees. The same comparisons show an increase of about 37 percent from 20 to 45 degrees. So the last step, from 35 to 45 degrees, adds only about 8 percent. A deeper trough has these costs: a more flexible belt, a longer transition at each pulley, and less free belt edge for a skirt seal.

How far apart should troughing idlers be spaced?

Common carrying spacing is about 4.5 to 5.5 feet on an 18" belt and 3.5 to 5 feet on a 36" belt. On a 60" belt, it is 3 to 4 feet. On a 96" belt, it is 2 to 3.5 feet. Return rolls are around 8 to 10 feet apart at any width. Through the load zone, carrying idlers are spaced at half that spacing or less. The final spacing comes from belt sag. Belt sag is belt weight plus material weight, times spacing squared, divided by eight times the tension. Spacing is squared, so small changes in spacing change sag a lot.

Does a deeper trough angle need a different idler class?

A deeper trough angle can need a different class on a wide belt. Published load rating tables hold the full class rating at all three trough angles across the narrow end of each class's belt-width range. The tables then derate the rating as the belt gets wider. Class C on a 36" belt is rated 900 lb at 20 degrees, 837 lb at 35 degrees, and 810 lb at 45 degrees. On a 60" belt, it is rated 700 lb, 650 lb, and 630 lb. If that derating pushes the calculated load past the rating, the fix is a heavier class or closer spacing.

What roll diameter should a troughing idler have?

Diameter depends more on belt speed than on load. The rule of thumb is roughly a 4" roll up to 400 feet per minute. The rule is 5" around 500 feet per minute, and 6" around 600 feet per minute. The diameter increases from there. At the same belt speed, a 4" roll turns 50 percent more rpm than a 6" roll. So it uses up its bearing life faster, and it has a thinner shell. The class limits the choice. Class C offers 4", 5", and 6" rolls. Class D offers 5" and 6" rolls. Rolls of 7" start at class E.

Need the idlers sized to your material instead of a catalog page?

Talk directly with the people who design and weld your conveyor. Monday to Thursday, 7:00 AM to 4:30 PM Pacific.

Call the Shop Get a Quote